Share for friends:

Read Sail Of Stone (2012)

Sail of Stone (2012)

Online Book

Rating
3.44 of 5 Votes: 1
Your rating
ISBN
1451608500 (ISBN13: 9781451608502)
Language
English
Publisher
simon & schuster

Sail Of Stone (2012) - Plot & Excerpts

I'm a big fan of Scandinavian crime novels and had high expectations from a three-time winner of the Swedish Crime Writers' award. Unfortunately, Sail of Stone disappointed in many ways.While I like a minimalistic style, the writing in this book is too disjointed (perhaps a direct translation from the Swedish?). Paragraphs are mostly series of choppy, incomplete sentences. For example: "Franz dropped the pistol, then picked it up. Franz lost his balance. Then Franz was on his way out, a yard from the door. He reeled suddenly." Writing like this slows the pace to a crawl. The dialogue is also quite stilted and repetitious. Characters often ask each other, "What do you mean?", then we get a repeat of what was already said. There's also a lot of one-word back-and-forth dialogue which strings out a simple conversation far too long.Besides issues with the writing/translation, the plots, although intriguing in theory, are weak. Most of the space given to Aneta's storyline involves her running around trying to locate Anette, instead of advancing the plot. Those pages should have been spent expanding on the relationships among the characters, especially Anette, Susanne, and Forsblad.There are also many weaknesses concerning John Osvald's storyline. Mainly (without giving anything away), why is everyone so angst-ridden about the past events? Axel's reaction seems particularly overwrought. I would have liked these actions/reactions to the past explored in more depth.Despite the flaws, I wanted to finish the book to see how the various storylines resolved. Unfortunately I was disappointed by the ending as well. It felt as if a few chapters were missing. An open-ended resolution is fine as long as there are enough details to make educated guesses about the future. This ending just made me feel frustrated.I'm not sure if I'll give Edwardson another try. If so, I'll go back the first Winter book and hope the writing and plot are tighter.

Beginning in Gothenburg, Sweden, this latest in the series featuring Chief Inspector Erik Winter moves mysteriously back and forth between Sweden and Scotland. Writing in his stream of consciousness style, Edwardson takes us inside the heads of Chief Inspector Winter, who travels to Scotland on the trail of a missing person who just happens to be the father of an old girl friend. Winters wrestles with his own feelings as well as the questions involved in a case where the only living witness suffers from dementia. The old girl friend and her brother report their father missing after he has gone off to Scotland, possibly in search of his own father, who disappeared off the coast of Scotland at the beginning of World War II. When they don’t hear from him for several days, they assume the worst, but how do they begin? At the same time, detective Aneta Djanali is searching for a woman who may be the victim of abuse, if she could only be located. Her investigations lead to the discovery of a ring of thieves who are systematically cleaning out apartments in Gothenburg, and the missing woman’s father may, or may not, be involved.The story is realistic in the way the characters’ thoughts wander to personal issues even as they strategize about how to approach the cases they are working on. Inevitably their personal issues and relationships become intertwined with the cases.Sail of Stone is a journey into the minds and emotions of the characters as well as the physical journey from Sweden to Scotland, and this physical journey becomes the crux of the solution to Winter’s feelings about his life, and well as providing the solution to a 70 year old mystery.

What do You think about Sail Of Stone (2012)?

Chief Inspector Erik Winter of the Gothenburg police department is contacted by an ex-girlfriend whose father has disappeared. The missing man had received a note referring to the disappearance of his own father during the Second World War after his boat sank off the coast of Scotland. Winter assumes the missing man has travelled to Aberdeen to investigate his father’s disappearance, and despite his own family priorities, Winter becomes sucked into the case. Meanwhile, Detective Aneta Djnali investigates the disappearance of a woman whom she believes to have been abused by her husband. The woman’s family seem determined to prevent Aneta from investigating the disappearance and deny that there is a problem. As Eric and Aneta delve deeper into their respective cases, the secrets of families and the lengths they will go to ensure they they remain hidden becomes apparent.This is a difficult book to review because the slow moving narrative made it hard to ever completely engage with the story. The account of Eric’s investigation and his travels to Scotland to look into the man’s disappearance was by far the most interesting aspect of the story. Although there are clearly links between Scotland and Scandinavia, Eric seems overwhelmed by the very strangeness of the place and looking at the granite city through a stranger’s eyes was fascinating.In his investigations, Winter is reunited with the British policeman Steve MacDonald who has appeared in previous books. They have an easy going relationship based on mutual respect and although the resolution of the case was slightly unbelievable I still enjoyed it. The investigation undertaken by Aneta in Sweden was more difficult to engage with and without giving any spoilers, I was left perplexed by the whole incident at the end of the book.
—Sarah

I have enjoyed four previous books in this series. Edwardson's main character Chief Inspector Erik Winter is less gloomy than Mankell's Kurt Wallander, younger, more urban. The ongoing support cast of police colleagues and family bring a different edge and are always interesting. Sail of Stone spins out two cases – they stay more or less parallel from start to finish. Though unconnected, they also subtly mirror each other thematically. Erik Winter travels from an old island fishing community off the Swedish coast to the same kind of isolated ports in northwest Scotland in a missing person/maybe murder case; his colleague Aneta Djanali puzzles out an apparent domestic abuse case back in Gothenburg. I was more engaged by the latter. The author devotes inordinate time and pages providing beautiful descriptions of the sea and the fishing life; it almost reads like a travel book when we get to Scotland, and the actual mystery there drags - especially when set against the neurotic tension of Aneta’s investigation. But Ake Edwardson is definitely a masterful writer. Recommended. Although maybe try an earlier one in the series if it’s your first.)
—John Brooke

Inspector Winter series is fantastic, and this book is no exception.Brilliant characters, and not just the world class inspector himself, but his teammates (especially Aneta, an afro-Swedish detective) and the people involved and being investigated. Complex plots, strong sense of places and history, and an atmosphere thick enough to need a knife to cut it. And now I want to visit the places mentioned in Scotland, and try some of the Scotch mentioned...There were two main stories being investigated, and while they developed hand in hand, at times they seemed a bit too separate. Some of the dialogs were a bit odd every now and then, but it's perhaps down to people saying different things in different languages. It's not how you'd say something in Swedish, but what you'd say instead. Not in a bad way, as it fit the characters. And it's definitely the characters who set the pace in the book. Just like it should be.
—Anna

Write Review

(Review will shown on site after approval)

Read books by author Åke Edwardson

Read books in series inspector winter

Read books in category Graphic Novels & Comics