Claire has created a unique problem for Santa. She's in perfect balance; not good enough for his 'Nice' list, but not bad enough for his 'Naughty' list. To get onto his 'Nice' list, Santa says Claire must make up for her bad deeds, AND do one good deed. He's brought some friends along to help her out; every man she has wronged this year, each equipped with a magic-enhanced erection that can't wait to make her pay. Once she's atoned for each crime, Santa himself plans to take her on. But will he be more than she can handle?